Consumers Needs Your Permission To Bury Wires On Your Land

Consumers Energy has embarked on a project to make our power around Lake Allegan more reliable. Part of this project is buyring wires underground so they don't get knocked down by wind or snow and rebuilding overhead lines to be more resilient. But, to bury wires on your property, they need permission from you. So, Consumers Energy and its contractors may have asked you or may be asking you to sign an easement giving them that permission.

When someone approaches you from Consumers Energy, you should verify that the person is in fact a representative from Consumers Energy.

How to Verify that the Consumers Energy Rep is Legit:

1. Call Consumers Energy Security Command – (800) 760-3295

*If the regular 800 number is called, they will need to ask to speak with Security Command as those in the Call Center may not have access to the proper records to verify.

2. Check the badges and door hangers. Below are pictures of the badges worn by both CE employees and authorized contractors, along with a picture of the door hangers that may be left by agents if people aren’t home when they visit.  

Official Consumers Energy Door Hanger	Official Consumers Energy Badges

3. Below are the people currently working on this project.

Bill Jenness – Real Estate Project Manager (Consumers Energy)

Jeff Goodheart – Contract Real Estate Project Manager (Contract Land Staff)

Jerry Paquette – Contract Senior Field Agent (Contract Land Staff)

Jim Fortino – Contract Senior Field Agent (Liberty Core)

*All live in Michigan and have Michigan phone numbers.

Read Our Rebuttal to the Michigan DNR

In December, the Michigan DNR head of fisheries, James Dexter, sent a fairly scathing diatribe against dams and dam communities to Consumers and FERC. We have prepared a rebuttal and sent it to Consumers and FERC, which you can see below or download.

When we read Mr. Dexter's rants, many of us were horrified, some of us were amused, but we were all certain that we had to respond. Essentially, Mr. Dexter argues that those of us who love dam lakes - like Lake Allegan - are silly hearts with emotional (his word) attachments to infrastructure, and that dams need to come down as the only way to help fish swim the length of the river. The problems with Mr. Dexter's arguments are that:

(a) we are living humans with a clear-eyed view of our lake and our future here; and

(b) removing the dam would unleash parasitic sea lamprey as well as sediment up and down the river and into Lake Michigan. (There are other problems, you should really read our letter).

I'd like to make a personal statement here with which many of my friends around Lake Allegan will disagree: I love and believe in government. I believe government is or ought to be a collaboration to solve common problems and make life easier for us all. And, so I'm always surprised when a government official disregards the experience, needs and testimony of the citizens he serves. It shocks my conscious.

Certainly, the people who desire clear fish passage deserve representation too; we are sympathetic to their concern for the importance of free-flowing fish. But, the consequences of deconstructing dams around the state to favor fish over people without basic civil regard for the human stakes are astonishing to us.

We can fix the problems of fish passage without crushing whole communities. Let's work together on solving these common problems to make life easier for us all.

DNR Rebuttal Letter • Lake Allegan Association, Inc. • March 7, 2023

.pdf

Download PDF • 244KB

VIA UPS & EMAIL March 7, 2023

Mr. Adam Monroe

Executive Director

Consumers Energy Hydro Generation

330 Chestnut Street

Cadillac, Michigan 49601 RE: Response of the Lake Allegan Association, Inc. -to- Michigan Department of Natural Resources detailed comments on Consumers Energy’s long-term Hydro Power Strategy Review

Dear Mr. Monroe:

We–the Lake Allegan Association, Inc.–have studied the comments of James L. Dexter, Fisheries Division Chief, Michigan Department of Natural Resources, delivered to you on December 29, 2022 and also provided to FERC. Here is our response.

We Understand That Dams Impact Fish

Mr. Dexter opens his letter with the assertion that the public is unfamiliar with the restrictions a dam may have on the ability of fish to swim freely. Mr. Dexter is wrong.

We live on the shores of Lake Allegan, a 1,587-acre impoundment made in 1935 by the Calkins Bridge Dam. Many of us fish and are deeply committed to the environment, the biosphere and conservation. We are acutely aware that often dams can prevent the free passage of fish through Michigan’s lakes, rivers, and other waters. That is why we as a lake association have an active committee made up of scientists, engineers and biologists–Environment and Fish Passage–devoted to the study and implementation of modern fish passage solutions at Calkins Bridge Dam.

Fish Passage Can Work

Mr. Dexter next asserts that dam removal is the only solution to ensure that fish flow freely. He is wrong.

Fish passage can be achieved with more modern, man-made solutions. Effective upstream fish passage technologies exist and continue to be developed. Technology solutions also exist for safe downstream fish passage, including turbines made by Natel Energy, Alden, and others.[i][ii] We are frankly dismayed that the Chief of the DNR Fisheries Division is either unaware of, or hardened to, the extensive progress made around the globe in fish passage technologies. His own agency serves as an advisor to the Boardman River FishPass project,[iii] working directly with Whooshh Innovations, Inc., [iv] whose modern fish passage systems have been successfully deployed at many hydroelectric dams.

To paint all dams with such a broad brush disregards both people and science. Not all dams should be removed. In fact, the Low Impact Hydropower Institute (LIHI)[v] has certified 177 hydropower dams for their minimal negative environmental impact. LIHI’s stringent criteria require dams to ensure upstream fish passage; downstream fish passage and protection; protect threatened and endangered species; protect shoreline and watershed; and preserve and provide recreational resources. The LIHI-certified dams represent a broad spectrum of dam sizes, generating capacity, and impoundment sizes. Clearly, solutions are available to address DNR’s Calkins Bridge fish-passage concerns.

Dams can be compatible with fish passage. We are disappointed that the stewards of Lake Allegan—including the DNR and its personnel entrusted with protecting and promoting diverse fisheries—have failed to require the repair or rehabilitation of the existing fish ladder at Calkins Dam. Mr. Dexter’s offhand mention of the broken fish ladder at Calkins Dam seems more like a surrender than a credible condemnation of all dams.

Most importantly, removal of Calkins Dam would potentially solve one problem but cause dozens more. Those problems would be devastating, far outweighing the single, potential benefit.

Calkins Dam Protects Against Invasive Species

Calkins Bridge Dam serves as a critical barrier to invasive species migration. Mr. Dexter mentions, but evades the gravity of, the dam’s sea lamprey barrier role. According to a consortium of government agencies,

“The sea lamprey (Petromyzon marinus) is a destructive, invasive species in the Great Lakes that contributed to the collapse of lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush) and other native species in the mid-20th century and continues to impede efforts to restore and rehabilitate the fish community. Sea lamprey subsist on the blood and body fluids of large-bodied fish. It is estimated that about half of sea lamprey attacks result in the death of their prey.[vi]

Millions of dollars are invested every year in containing and killing sea lamprey so they do not wipe out substantial portions of the fish population in the Great Lakes and its tributaries. In 2017, scientists from Michigan State University studied Calkins Dam and two others in Michigan and concluded that removal of any of these dams would quickly result in a devastating increase in sea lamprey populations. Further, the Great Lakes Fishery Commission names Calkins Bridge Dam as critical to its ability to successfully control this invasive species. [vii]

We Have Much at Stake – and So Does the State of Michigan.

Mr. Dexter explains that Consumers Energy should dissuade the public from expecting that dams will remain in perpetuity because people in local communities have strong ‘emotional connections’ to ‘infrastructure developed around the dams.’

In communities across the nation, people make their homes, livelihoods, rest, and recreation around such ‘infrastructure.’ These man-made lakes buttress our own state’s very brand: Pure Michigan. Lake Allegan is 88 years old—decades in which the lake has become embedded in the hearts and estates of generations of Michiganders. We find it curious that an official entrusted with the imprimatur of a state agency would seek to talk citizens out of loving the land and water of the State of Michigan.

Emotion is not all we have at stake. Our community, and the Allegan community at large, risk significant economic consequences if the dam is removed.

Based on public tax records, the market value of Lake Allegan frontage and backlot properties is approximately $124 million, generating $2 million in property taxes in 2022. Owners of Lake Allegan-adjacent property pay 45% of Valley Township’s tax revenues.

Our analysis, drawn from a parcel-by-parcel review,[viii] shows that a 30% loss of frontage-property value, coupled with a more conservative 10% backlot value loss, would reduce annual property tax revenues by more than $500,000—of which some $338,000 would no longer go to our schools.[ix] Moreover, this loss does not include lake owners’ and users’ contributions to area businesses, which would be casualties of the economic domino effect should Calkins Bridge Dam be removed.

Lake Allegan is not the only community exposed to economic dam-removal jeopardy. We are in active dialogue with leaders from dam communities across the state. Consistently we are told that if the dams were removed, the tourism and second-homeism that support lake and pond communities would evaporate. Imagine the ripple effects of destroying a dozen local economies across Michigan. The economic ecosystems of our communities, including schools, hospitals and businesses, would collapse. The State – having broken these communities - would have to step in to fix them.

All Infrastructure–Including Calkins Bridge Dam–is Impermanent and in Need of Periodic Rehabilitation.

Mr. Dexter implies that the public needs to be taught that dams around the lake are not permanent, so we shouldn’t get too attached to them.

We recognize that Calkins Bridge Dam—and every dam—was not built to last ‘in perpetuity.’ Neither are our nation’s highways, bridges, and water treatment plants. Repair, and especially renewals that enhance utility, longevity, and efficiency comprise standard infrastructure management that rejects the throwaway approach DNR advocates for the Consumers Energy dams. Responsible infrastructure stewardship, whether over a state, a dam, a road, or a home, actively governs and extends the useful life of structures.

River Hydro is Surging

Mr. Dexter appears to view all thirteen dams as burdensome infrastructure ‘that is no longer economical’ and poses ‘impacts and risks that are no longer justifiable.’ Such a one-size-fits-all approach is short-sighted.

We are not alone in recognizing the logic of strategic investment in river hydro in lieu of its wholesale eradication.

Our federal legislators understand that investing in existing river hydro is essential to maintaining grid reliability. 2021’s Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act[x]signed into law by President Biden includes incentive payments to owners or operators of existing hydroelectric facilities to fund capital improvements that can increase efficiency by at least three percent. Bipartisan U.S. Senate legislation introduced in December 2022, the Maintaining and Enhancing Hydropower and River Restoration Act and the 21st Century Dam Act, [xi][xii][xiii] will support investments in fish passage, sediment management, and upgrade or replacement of floodgates and spillways.

Stanford University’s ‘Uncommon Dialogue’[xiv] group calls for rehabilitating and retrofitting dams to improve safety, increase renewable energy generation, and enhance operations for fish passage, among other outcomes. Uncommon Dialogue is a collaboration among environmental and river conservation groups, dam safety advocates, and the hydropower industry. They recognize that hydroelectric power generation is an essential component of a broad strategy for achieving reliable, affordable, renewable energy. The group does recognize that some dams should be removed if they no longer benefit society or have safety or environmental impacts that cannot be cost-effectively mitigated. None of these applies to Calkins Bridge Dam.

For yet another well-reasoned and balanced approach to dam removal, consider this passage from the most recent issue of the academic journal Fisheries Research:[xv]

Many biologists and fisheries managersin various institutions and regulatory agencies likely desire to see dam removed to facilitate the return of rivers to a natural free flowing condition. While there are likely many dams within the LS [Lake Sturgeon] range that may have outlivedtheir life expectancy, original intent, and/or usefulness, there are likely many more that continue to efficiently function to create hydropower, as well as maintain impoundments that support important recreational and commercial fisheries, important aquatic habitats, water recreation, flood control, waterfront properties and infrastructure, andlocal economies. Also, there are likely many river systems where a dam was originally placed at the site of a natural bedrock break or waterfall - which originally acted as a natural fish migration barrier – to take advantageof the natural head for hydropower production. ... Each dam needs to be dealt with on a case-by-case or context-specific basis…

At a time when renewable energy groups are calling for non-powered dams to be retrofitted for power generation, and when federal dollars are available to support enhanced efficiency of existing river hydro plants, DNR’s shut-them-all-down position seems irresponsible and behind the times.

Electricity Pricing is Too Complex to Localize Costs

Mr. Dexter suggests that dam maintenance costs should not be passed through to ratepayers because the dams generate too little power. Although we are unclear how much weight should be placed on the electricity pricing views of the DNR chief of fisheries, we are certain that Mr. Dexter’s approach is deeply flawed.

Energy rates are a complex rubric of costs, overhead, interest and assistance. The Michigan Public Utilities Commission (MPSC) constructs residential energy rates as an umbrella covering a variety of charges that begin with distribution and supply and extend to the full spectrum of activities involved in bringing power to the people.[xvi] Low-income energy assistance, nuclear plant decommissions, private power company transitions to renewable energy, and bond securitization are some of the activities whose costs MPSC amortizes inside residential energy rates. These activities occur in different pockets of the state, some that are more cost effective than others, some that affect more people than others. But these costs are shared across the broad population. Michigan’s residential electricity rates are not and cannot be based merely on a cost/benefit analysis that considers only the scope and scale of a utility’s power-generating assets. We find it notable that the costs of river hydro – a primarily rural phenomenon – should be excluded from all the other activities that we Michiganders should share. In any event, Mr. Dexter’s approach to energy rates envisions a model that does not reflect how energy rates are actually determined in a modern Michigan.

Mr. Dexter omits from his rate discussion the toxic costs from coal, oil, and gas—a price we all pay in higher health costs and environmental cleanup. Hydroelectric dams do not impose the same externalized costs, because they don’t belch CO2 into the atmosphere. Under Mr. Dexter’s rate model, we all shoulder these very real costs; they just don’t show up on our monthly electric bill so somehow they do not count.

Finally, Mr. Dexter’s pricing philosophy ignores and poses a powerful disincentive to the alternate approach, which is to invest in plant upgrades and technology enhancements that can render even aging hydro operations more productive and more cost-effective.

We would encourage Mr. Dexter and DNR to lobby MPSC to change its rate-setting approach. MPSC could incentivize river hydro investment aimed at increasing efficiency and grid resilience—generating cleaner and greener power than other sources—while requiring operators to also achieve performance metrics related to fish passage, water quality, and recreational access.

Under the current cost-of-service rate regulation, as applied by MPSC, investments in river hydro plants—even FERC-mandated safety outlays—have been largely excluded on the premise they benefit only ratepayers in the dams’ narrowly defined geographic footprints.[xvii] A performance-based rate-setting approach, which MPSC is already evaluating, [xviii] would be better suited to attaining many of the natural resources goals DNR champions. [xix]

Calkins Dam Is Here to Stay

We are not naïve. We know that some dams pose a threat to public safety, have outlived their utility, and should be dismantled. Calkins Dam is not that.

Calkins Bridge is rated a low-hazard dam with no safety issues that we have identified in public regulatory filings. The dam’s environmental impact is clearly positive: it prevents Lake Allegan’s embedded PCBs from flowing downstream. In its Superfund oversight role, EPA recently approved a PCB-remediation feasibility study of Lake Allegan.[xx] The study will include evaluating monitored natural recovery (MNR) among other remediation alternatives. Earlier testing suggests MNR is already well underway. If approved as part of the final remediation program, MNR would reduce cleanup costs by many multiples. Moreover, this approach would over time permit lake fish consumption without triggering a lake-removal economic domino effect that would devastate our community.

Lake Allegan is also home to hundreds of people who contribute financially, morally, spiritually, and materially to the state and the region. Thousands of people visit Lake Allegan to fish, swim, boat and play. Lake Allegan is beautiful and loved, even if man-made, even if mildly polluted, even if imperfect. We are committed to this land and water. Lake Allegan is here to stay.

Lake Allegan Association, Inc. Must Have a Seat at the Table.

Mr. Dexter does make a comment on which we agree. He expresses his concern about the future stewardship of Calkins Bridge Dam if Consumers Energy surrenders its license and transfers the property to a new owner. Mr. Dexter states that any transferee must have sufficient financial resources and technical capabilities to ensure the dam’s long-term safety, and to cover safety and maintenance needs. He notes that insurance and other financial mechanisms, plus top-quality, diligent, and well-funded monitoring and maintenance, are crucial.

We agree. Frankly, we will be surprised if Consumers abandons river hydro at Calkins Dam. And, we take the people of Consumers Energy at their word that they intend to be responsible and faithful to the community surrounding Lake Allegan. We are open and optimistic about Lake Allegan’s future. But we do require that Lake Allegan remain a lake, that it continue to improve in quality and cleanliness, that the dam remain safe and well maintained, and that we play an active role in its future.

We look forward to continued engagement with Consumers Energy.

If you have questions about our position or the information included herein, I can be reached at coco@lakeallegan.org.

Sincerely,

Coco Soodek

President, Lake Allegan Association, Inc. www.lakeallegan.org

cc: Mr. James L. Dexter, Michigan DNR

Mr. Josh Burgett, Consumers Energy

Mr. David Mcintosh, Consumers Energy

Ms. Maggie Pallone, Public Sector Consultants

Ms. Elizabeth Riggs, Public Sector Consultants

Mr. Todd Grischke, Michigan DNR

Mr. Patrick Ertel, Michigan DNR

Dr. Michael Siefkes, Great Lakes Fishery Commission

Daniel Eichinger, Acting Director, EGLE

Dan Scripps, Tremaine Phillips, & Katherine Peretick, Commissioners, MPSC

[i]Natel Energy. Our Technology: The Restoration Hydro Turbine (RHT) is designed to be the most fish-safe, high-performance, compact turbine in the world, reducing permitting and installation costs, while supporting downstream fish passage. https://www.natelenergy.com/ [ii] Olbertz, Niklas. Sustainable hydro-power plants with focus on fish-friendly turbine design. EGU Journal of Renewable Energy Short Reviews, 2021. https://www.hb.fh-muenster.de/opus4/files/13687/13_Olbertz_EGUJRenEnRev_2021.pdf [iii] Great Lakes Fishery Commission, FishPass. http://www.glfc.org/fishpass.php [iv] Whooshh Innovations, Inc. Our Innovations Might Just Be Your Solutions, Fish Passage. https://www.whooshh.com/Our-Innovations/products [v] Some states utilize the LIHI Certification Program in determining hydropower eligibility for Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) inclusion and compliance. [vi] Sea Lamprey Control in the Great Lakes 2021. Mike Steeves Fisheries and Oceans Canada Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario Jessica Barber United States Fish and Wildlife Service Marquette, Michigan [vii] Great Lakes Fishery Commission. Letter to Mr. Josh Burgett, Executive Director, Community Engagement & Corporate Citizenship, CMS Energy Corporation, dated 12-28-2022. Letter conveys GLFC’s position regarding the role of Consumers Energy’s hydro dams in the control of invasive sea lamprey. Letter available to the public at https://elibrary.ferc.gov/eLibrary/search , using the accession search tool and accession number 20230109-5084. [viii] Lake Allegan Association, Inc. Property tax analysis drawn from Allegan County Parcel Viewer, https://gis.allegancounty.org/portal_webadaptor/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=2ec1c68c8edc4ef595f41cc10596f3eb using county tax levy and millage data available at https://www.allegancounty.org/home/showpublisheddocument/9990/638042733115700000. Analysis information: contact press@lakeallegan.org [ix] Our estimate of a 30% loss in value is supported by a 2013 U.S. Department of the Interior study of real property on the Klamath River (Oregon and California) which posited that dam removals would reduce the affected properties’ values by some 30%. The Klamath River study most closely resembles Lake Allegan owners’ at-risk properties. [x] U.S. Department of Energy. Biden Administration Launches $630 Million in Programs to Modernize Nation's Hydropower Fleet. June 30, 2022. https://www.energy.gov/articles/biden-administration-launches-630-million-programs-modernize-nations-hydropower-fleet [xi] U.S. Department of Energy, Grid Deployment Office. Hydroelectric Incentives Funding in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. https://www.energy.gov/gdo/hydro [xii] Congress.gov. S.2306 - Maintaining and Enhancing Hydroelectricity and River Restoration Act of 2021, 117th Congress (2021-2022).https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/2306?overview=closed [xiii] United States Senator for Alaska Lisa Murkowski. Cantwell, Murkowski Bill Would Spur Hydropower Upgrades, Restore Free Flowing Rivers. Press release dated 12-09-22. https://www.murkowski.senate.gov/press/release/cantwell-murkowski-bill-would-spur-hydropower-upgrades-restore-free-flowing-rivers-#:~:text=The%20Maintaining%20and%20Enhancing%20Hydroelectricity,at%20our%20nation's%20hydropower%20dams. [xiv] https://woods.stanford.edu/research/hydropower/hydropower-ucd-overview [xv] Bruch, Ronald M. and Haxton, Tim J, Cost and relative effectiveness of Lake Sturgeon passage systems in the US and Canada. Fisheries Research Volume 257, January 2023. Available at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0165783622002879?via%3Dihub . [xvi] Residential Energy Bill Charges (a publication of the MPSC). Available at https://www.michigan.gov/-/media/Project/Websites/mpsc/consumer/info/tips/electric_residential_bill_charges_final.pdf?rev=e80ef0b163614800b1d8910b9e781775. [xvii] Michigan Public Service Commission. Rate case U-21224. See the 2-28-2022 direct testimony of Adam J. Monroe of Consumers Energy, describing investments the company deems needed to ensure safe and reliable operation of its hydro facilities, including those required by FERC. Available at: Torrey_TE_ERC.docx (force.com).Then see the 8-24-2022 direct testimony of Jonathan J. DeCooman of MPSC, in the same rate case, where he finds those investments to be ineligible for collection from ratepayers. Available at: 0688y000003yBzXAAU (force.com). [xviii] Michigan Public Service Commission, Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs. Report on the Study of Performance-Based Regulation. Prepared in compliance with Act 341 of 2016. Available at https://www.michigan.gov/documents/mpsc/MI_PBR_Report_Final_621112_7.pdf [xix] Rocky Mountain Institute / RMI. States Move Swiftly on Performance-Based Regulation to Achieve Policy Priorities. March 31, 2022. https://rmi.org/states-move-swiftly-on-performance-based-regulation-to-achieve-policy-priorities/ (RMI is a non-partisan, non-profit organization that works to transform global energy systems across the real economy.) [xx] Area 6 Supplemental Remediation Investigation/ Feasibility Study (SRI/FS) Work Plan for the Allied Paper, Inc./Portage Creek/Kalamazoo River Site, Operable Unit 5 (OU 5). Submitted June 21, 2002 to James Saric, Remedial Project Manager, USEPA Region 5. See also Mr. Saric’s letter approving the SRI as submitted. Both documents are available at https://foiaonline.gov/foiaonline/action/public/submissionDetails?trackingNumber=EPA-R5-2023-000456&type=Request

Governor Whitmer: Add River Hydro to Your Power Plan

We - the Lake Allegan Association, Inc. - along with friends of dams around the state - have asked Governor Whitmer to put river hydro into the state's renewable energy plan and to meet with us. We did this in a letter that was released today. You can read that letter here or download it from the link at the bottom.

Lake Allegan - Best Dam Lake

This was the brainchild of Carol Doeringer, our fantastic head of Media and Communications. Carol noticed that the plan adopted by the state of Michigan for renewable energy - the MI Healthy Climate Plan - did not include river hydropower as a source of green renewable power. We all believe this is a serious deficiency in an otherwise solid plan.

Our letter to the Governor has been promoted by dam communities across the state, particularly the terrific people in Iosco County and Plainfield Township.

385 Michiganders have signed the letter.

We hope Governor Whitmer or someone from her staff will meet with us to discuss the importance of river hydro to maintain energy stability throughout our state.

The Lake Allegan Association, Inc. is committed to protecting the environment, energy production and Lake Allegan. You can download and/or read the letter below.

---

Hydro Communities' Open Letter to Gov Whitmer Final, Signed, Feb 22, 2023

.pdf

Download PDF • 285KB

AN OPEN LETTER TO GOVERNOR GRETCHEN WHITMER

February 22, 2023 Dear Governor Whitmer: We are Michiganders who may soon face the loss of lifelong investments in homes and communities by a potential plan to eliminate hydroelectric dams in Michigan. We ask you to join us in continued support of river hydro as a pillar of renewable and clean power. Our request comes at a time when at least one Michigan power company, Consumers Energy, is re-evaluating its century-long river hydro commitment.

Add River Hydro to Your MI Healthy Climate Plan

As you know, under your leadership, Michigan adopted the MI Healthy Climate Plan. It calls for Michigan to increase its carbon-neutral electricity to 60% by 2030 and to 100% by 2050. Your plan admits that ‘to achieve our goals,’ we must ‘avoid actions … that make it more difficult to reach carbon neutrality’ and 'maintain existing clean energy and energy storage assets.’

Yet nowhere does this 58-page plan mention Michigan’s river hydro operations. We view this omission as the rare oversight in an otherwise exceptional program. Omitting river hydro from Michigan’s renewable energy resources hinders your own plan and our state’s chances of achieving its necessary goals. Michigan has a wealth of river hydro resources at a time when environmental and hydropower experts are calling for state and federal investments in river hydro plants. Instead of omitting river hydro, Michigan’s climate plan should embrace substantial funding for what one environmental working group calls ‘innovative approaches to a climate-ready, river-friendly hydropower industry.’ 1

We ask you to revise the MI Healthy Climate Plan to include river hydro as a fundamental pillar in Michigan’s green and renewable future.

Encourage Your Agencies to Support River Hydro

We also note that your plan requires the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to ‘analyze and more fully consider the potential community health and environmental impacts of utility investment decisions.’ We endorse the plan’s commitment to environmental justice. But MPSC must also recognize and consider economic and recreational injustice to communities, and to all state residents that use these facilities, if dams are removed.

The 13 Dams Under Review Span the State

Right now, Consumers Energy is reviewing whether it will continue to generate hydropower at thirteen dams. These 13 dams support Michigan communities in eight counties. These communities, our state’s tourism industry, and Consumers Energy have benefited enormously from the ponds, lakes, and impoundments formed by these dams. Consumers Energy claims that MPSC’s resistance to allowing some rate elasticity is hindering the company’s ability to keep up with dam maintenance, threatening the future of river hydro at these 13 dams.

A case in point: In March 2022, Consumers applied to MPSC for a rate increase, presenting costs, totaling over $350 million, needed for safety and reliability upgrades to its Hardy dam. The case is still pending, but MPSC currently rejects Consumer’s request to increase rates to fund these upgrades, which Consumers says are required to maintain its operating license.

We are not in favor of excessive power rates. But MPSC’s resistance to cost recovery for safety upgrades seems both dangerous and counterproductive. Your plan calls for an ambitious expansion of Michigan’s clean energy resources. Yet MPSC’s stance invites power companies to abandon their river hydro assets.

Removing the dams would strip communities of their lifeblood. Property values and commerce would fall, reducing tax revenues that support schools and community needs. Our recreational waters and related camping, hunting, and other outdoor activities would suffer, both for residents and for visitors whose dollars anchor many of our areas’ economies. It is certain that dam removal would harm Michigan’s hydro communities; the damage would flow throughout the state. We need your help to ensure that does not happen.

Please encourage the MPSC to prioritize preserving all forms of renewable power and communities. Governor Whitmer, retaining river hydro and our dams is undeniably consistent with your environmental policy objectives. River hydro must remain an essential element of Michigan’s clean energy future. For these reasons, we ask you to turn policy into practice: Invest in river hydro.Work with Consumers Energy and its regulators to protect our dams and to ensure the viability of our communities.

To this end, we would welcome an opportunity to meet with you and your environmental policy leaders. Will you give us an opportunity to more fully detail our position and perspective?

Yours truly, The undersigned Michiganders—People, businesses, officials, and organizations united to keep river hydro. (Please see our signatures on the following pages) CC: U.S. Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm CC: Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel CC: Dan Eichinger, Acting Director, EGLE ________________________________ [1]Innovative and Advanced Hydropower Technology Can Improve Environmental Performance, Generation Efficiency, and Grid Resilience, Uncommon Dialogue Working Group 1, October 2022. Under the auspices of The Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment, Working Group members include environmental organizations, hydropower companies, and key industry stakeholders. In 2021, members of Congress—including Reps. Debbie Dingell and Rashida Tlaib—endorsed this group’s recommendations and sent them to President Biden.

SIGNERS, many of whom named the Consumers Energy hydro dam(s) near where they live, work, or recreate:

Karen Abee, Greenbush (Foote)

Eric Ackerman, Oscoda (Foote)

Tera Albert, Oscoda (Foote)

Thomas Aldrich, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Shannon Allison, Oscoda (Foote)

Rebecca Allison, Oscoda (Foote)

Michael Alpert, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jannifer Anderson, Big Prairie Township Trustee (Hardy)

Evan Anderson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jeffrey Anderson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Brian Arnold, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Courtney Bachelor, Iosco County (Foote, Cooke, 5 Channels)

Dale Bachelor, Iosco County (Foote)

Karen Baiers, Valley Township, (Calkins Bridge)

Kim Baiers, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Bernadette Baker, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Dennis Baker, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Zach Baker, Oscoda Township (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Jay Balaban, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Darlene Balaban, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jordan Barclay, Member, Plainfield Twp Board of Review, Hale (Five Channels)

Matthew Barnett, Owner, Route 23 BBQ, Oscoda (Foote)

Brent Barringer, City Manager, City of East Tawas (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Kristi Benedict, Assn. Executive, Northeastern Michigan Board of Realtors (Cooke, Foote, Loud, & Five Channels)

Mark Benjamin, President, Benjamin Realty, Rose City (Mio)

Rick Birdsley, President, Turtle Cove at Lake Allegan HOA, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Alicia Bishop, Alcona County (Alcona)

Karen Bishop, Harrisville/Alcona County (Cooke & Foote)

Lee Blaser, National City/Iosco County (Cooke)

Scott Blaylock, Curtisville (Alcona)

Ed Bolanowski, Co-Managing Partner, Au Sable Developments LLC, Oscoda Township (Foote)

Kaitlin Bondie, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Shannone Bondie, Owner, Sterling Properties, Oscoda (Foote)

William Bonk, South Branch (Alcona)

Joseph Borst, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jim Boula, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Larry Boyce, Member, Northeastern Board of Realtors, Iosco County

Suzanne Bratton, Luzerne (Mio)

Christopher Brault, Oscoda (Foote)

Lydia Brenk, East Tawas (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Paul Brock, Oscoda (Foote)

Gloria Brooks, President, Develop Iosco, Inc., East Tawas (Five Channels)

Angela Brown, Oscoda

Gregory Brown, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Pia Brown, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Carlita Brown, Tawas City

Jennifer Buchanan, Au Gres

Chance Buckman, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Renae Burgess, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Janet Burgoyne, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

James Cain, Mecosta Township Trustee, Big Rapids (Rogers)

Erin Campbell-Brooks, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Valerie Capel, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Michael Capel, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Matthew Carpenter, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jamie Carruthers-Soboleski, County of Iosco Controller/Finance Director, Tawas City (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Tony Castro, Oscoda (Foote)

Tim Catherine, President, Holmbergs Safety Systems Inc., Kalamazoo (Calkins Bridge)

Richard Champine, Oscoda (Foote)

William Chaney, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Joann Chaney, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Janet Charters, Oscoda (Foote)

Maureen Chausse, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Colleen Clark, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Kristen Clignett, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Timothy Condor, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Tracy Condor, Oscoda (Foote)

Jeffrey Cotton, Iosco County (Cooke & Foote)

Casey Couzens, Glennie (Alcona)

Matthew Cowen, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Kathleen Coyle, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Wendy Cramer, Oscoda

John Cramer, Mikado (Foote)

Carson Crisp, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Brenda Crisp, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Antony Crofts, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Stephanie Crofts, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Charlotte Crofts, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Jim Croy, President, Indian Shores Property Owners Association, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Susan Croy, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Alex Cudone, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Misti Cudone, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Andrew Cudone, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Robert Cudone, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Andrew Currie, President, Currie Aviation LLC, Oscoda Township (Loud & Five Channels)

Timothy Curtis, Oscoda (Foote, Cooke, & Loud)

James Dalpizzol, Harrisville (Foote)

Mary V. Daoust, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Pam Davis, Oscoda Township (Foote & Cooke)

Heather Debusschere, Harrisville

Paul Deeds, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Chris Derry, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Don & Lynn Ditri, Plainfield Township (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, Loud, Alcona, & Mio)

David Dixon, South Branch (Alcona)

Ronald Doak, East Tawas (Five Channels)

Norbert Doeringer, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Carol Doeringer, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Richard Dutkiewicz, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Mel Duvall, East Tawas (Foote)

Katherine Dwyer, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Jennifer Dzuris, Harrisville (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, Loud, Alcona, & Mio)

Loetta Eberhardt, Oscoda (Cooke & Foote)

Dakota Eberhardt, Oscoda (Foote)

Rick Eberhardt, Oscoda (Foote)

Brandee Ellis, Valley Township Clerk, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Benjamin Elowski, Alpena

Daniel Esposito, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Maureen Esposito, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Janice Evans, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Nick Fairchild, Oscoda (Foote)

Richard Ferris, Realtor, East Tawas

Kyle Fishel, National City (Foote, Cooke, & Five Channels)

Joanne Flannery, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Mark Fleming, Oscoda, (Five Channels)

Christi Foster, Treasurer, Valley Township, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Brook Foster-Stalker, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Steven Franks, Chief, Greenbush Fire Dept, Greenbush (Foote)

Jewel Fritz, Tawas City

Cameron Fulton, Oscoda (Foote)

Anthony Garofalo, Chairman, Valley Township Zoning Board, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Elaine Gerbers, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Russ Gerbers, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Beverly Gibson, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Jamie Goodwin, Marquette

Michele Graham, Mecosta Township Supervisor, Big Rapids (Rogers)

Bradley Green, Oscoda (Foote)

Timothy Griffin, Mikado Township (Alcona)

Todd Grimes, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Melisa Gunnett, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Gene Gysin, Oscoda (Foote)

Jennifer Hacker, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Michael Haley

Joseph Handy, Tawas City (Five Channels, Cooke & Foote)

Jeffrey Hansen, Oscoda (Foote)

Stacey Harbour, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Don Harbour, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Meagan Hardin, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Chase Hardin, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

JoAnn Harmon, Mikado

Irene Hartman, Oscoda

Erik Heller, Oscoda

Kirsty Heller, Oscoda

A Hemgesberg, Mikado (Foote)

Trisha Henderson, Blendon Township (Calkins Bridge)

Jane Henry, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Pastor Scott Herbolsheimer, In His Presence Hale Assembly of God, Hale

Linda Hillary, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Brent Hinkley, Iosco (Foote & Cooke)

Stacy Hodges, Tawas City

Steven Hoin, Oscoda (Foote)

Jessica Holley, Oscoda (Foote)

Mary M Holzheuer, Member, Plainfield Township Board of Review, Hale (Foote)

Elizabeth Hostetler, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Kurt Hostetler, President, Waters Pointe Homeowners Assoc., Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Nicholas Hostetler, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Cruz Hubbell, Oscoda (Foote)

Cheryl Huber, All Star Real Estate, Bay City

Libda Hucjs, President, Iosco County Right to Life, Iosco County

Nancy Huebel, Clerk, County-of-Iosco

Martin Hulverson, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Rosemary Jack, Oscoda (Cooke)

Steven M. Jacus, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jaimie McGuire, Treasurer, Charter Township of Oscoda (Foote)

Jason Jakobi, Assistant Fire Chief, National City (Cooke)

Deb Janis, Tawas City (Foote)

John Janson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Susan Janson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Christine Johnson, Agent, Scofield Real Estate, Hale (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Susan Johnson, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Kelly Jones, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Carol Jurczyk, East Tawas (Cooke & Foote)

Joseph Kalafut, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Deborah Kalafut, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Christopher Kalinoski, East Tawas (Cooke)

Kyle Karas, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Mike Kelly, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jamie Klein, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Ronald and Peggy Klingenberg, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

A. Koenig, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Mike Kowalski, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Kaili Kubiac, Oscoda

Robert Laliberte, Oscoda (Foote)

Robert Lawson, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Megan LeRoux, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Ron Lesneski, Scofield Real Estate, LLC, Hale (Cooke)

Bernadette Lewis, Oscoda (Foote)

Fred Lewis, Supervisor, Plainfield Township, Hale (Five Channels , Loud , Cooke , Foote)

Forrest Linderman, Planning Chair, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Scott Lingo, Owner, Target Real Estate Company, East Tawas (Foote)

William Lixey, East Tawas

Brian Loeffler, Iosco Conservation District & Iosco County 4th District Commissioner, East Tawas

Alisha Louchart, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Kelleen Louchart, Oscoda

Blake Lunt, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Susan Lunt, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Brett Lynch, Mio (Mio)

Billie Lynch, Mio (Mio)

Christopher Malburg, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Randy Mallory, Mikado (Foote & Cooke)

Barbara Maness, Oscoda Township (Foote)

Chenoa Marklevitz, Oscoda

Anne Martin, East Tawas

Mark Martis, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Gregory Marzolino, Plainfield Township (Cooke)

Donna Matthews, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Chase Matthews, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Catherine McCarthy, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Stacy McClure, Iosco County

Cheryl McDonell, Member, Plainfield Township Planning Commission & Owner, Happy Acres Real Estate LLC, Hale

John McGeorge, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

MartyRose McLeod, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

James McLeod, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Brian McMurray, Mayor, Tawas City

Cheri Meier, Oscoda (Foote)

Angel Melendez, Oscoda (Loud)

Sandra Miller, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Tim Miller, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Cliff Miller, President, TCA Insurance, Tawas City

Michael Miller, East Tawas

Deborah Miner, Oscoda (Foote)

Betsy Mioduch, East Tawas (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

John Molenstra, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

William L. Morgan, Allegan County (Morgans, Inc.) (Calkins Bridge)

Scott Morgan, Oscoda (Foote)

Greg Morris, Owner, Morris Richardson Real Estate, West Branch

Joseph Moser, Mikado Township (Foote)

Diane Mraz, South Branch (Alcona)

Tonia Muckenthaler, Iosco County (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Kayla Murlick, Saginaw

Anna Mynsberge, Tawas City (Foote, Cooke, Alcona, Loud, & Mio)

Kevin Nagel, Realtor, Northeastern Michigan Board of Realtors, Houghton Lake

Ed Nagy, Council Member, Tawas City Council, Iosco County (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Pamela Neely-Blaylock, Curtisville Township (Alcona)

Deanna Nichols, Georgetown Township (Calkins Bridge)

Mason Nichols, Hudsonville (Calkins Bridge)

Lisa Osborn, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Maureen Owens, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Donald Pabis, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Sheila Palmer, Oscoda Township (Foote)

Elwin Pardee, Barton City

Roberta Parkhill, Grand Blanc

Angie Parsons, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Lilly Parsons, Grand Rapids (Calkins Bridge)

Mary Ann Peters, Long Lake (Loud)

Valarie Peterson, Oscoda (Five Channels)

John Pfeiffer, Oscoda (Foote)

Alysa Pichler, Oscoda County (Alcona)

James Pinnick Jr., Owner/President, Rollway Resort, Hale (Alcona, Loud, & Five Channels)

Julie Potts, East Tawas (Foote)

Tim Potts, Oscoda (Foote)

Heather Potts, Oscoda Township (Foote)

Donna Preisler, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

George Preisler, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Autumn Prouty, Oscoda (Foote)

Anthony Rappold, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Christina Raynak, Iosco (Foote)

Gerald Reckman, East Tawas (Cooke)

William Reidy, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jill Reidy, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Katelyn Reitenour, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Ron Remington, Supervisor, Valley Township Board (Calkins Bridge)

Ann Richards, Supervisor, Charter Township of Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Carrie Robinson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Robert Robinson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Tamera Robson, Glennie (Alcona)

Taylor Robson, Glennie (Alcona)

Andrew Rogers, Oscoda (Foote)

Amy Rogers, Oscoda (Foote)

Richard Rohn, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Kathy Rohn, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Quinton Root, Oscoda (Loud)

Jordan Rosenblum, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Michael Roth, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Joseph Rothove, Hubbard Lake (Foote)

Andy Roy, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Maureen Rudel, Treasurer, Iosco County Republicans, East Tawas (Foote)

Tina Ruedisueli, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

Ryen Sack, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Mary Sack, Brighton (Calkins Bridge)

Randy Schafer, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Joseph Schmidt, Mikado (Foote)

Todd Schnell, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Dan Schnitta, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Michael E. Schofield, Oscoda (Foote)

Steve Schulz, Allegan Township Supervisor (Calkins Bridge)r

Sarah Schwiderson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Keith Scott, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Jeff Senn, Oscoda Township (Foote & Cook)

Jo Ellen Serum, Associate Broker, Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realtors, Roscommon County

Marty Shearer, Iosco County

Allison Shelton, East Tawas (Foote & Cooke)

Zachary Shelton, Iosco (Foote)

Judy Shuler, Iosco County Democratic Party, Oscoda

Michael Sicard, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Rebecca Sichmeller, Valley Township, (Calkins Bridge)

Scott Sichmeller, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Russell Sidebottom, Oscoda (Foote Oscoda)

Megan Smith, Owner, North Country Canoe Rental, Oscoda (Foote)

Jerry Smith, East Tawas (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Kristen Smith, Oscoda

Carol Sneller, Broker/Owner, Coldwell Banker Sneller Real Estate, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Coco Soodek, President, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Robert Speaker, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Lynda Speaker, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

James Sposato, Mio (Mio)

Richard St.John, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Al and Judy Stadler, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

David Stafford, President, Lake Bluff Estates Homeowners Assn., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Cindy Stafford, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Jon Stalker, Oscoda (Foote & Cooke)

John Stanley, Associate Broker, Arenac Realty/Northeastern Michigan Board of Realtors, Au Gres (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Teresa Steinburg, Trowbridge Township (Calkins Bridge)

Melissa Stewart, Tawas Township Clerk

Eric Strayer, Superintendent, AuSable Township (Foote)

Ralph Stuba, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Kristin Stuba, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Rich Stuba, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Charlene Swain, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Karl Swarthout Jr, Oscoda (Foote)

James Szafran, Chair, Plainfield Township Board of Review, Hale (Foote)

Melissa Taylor, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Carla Teasdale, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Dave Theisinger, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Bette Thompson, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

David Thompson, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Mindi Thompson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Tracy Titman, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Vicki Tornga, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Luis Torregrosa, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Abigail Torregrosa, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Sharon Torregrosa, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Carlos Torregrosa, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

April Travis, Mikado (Foote, Cooke, & Five Channels)

Austin Tuck, Curtisville (Alcona)

Michele Turcich, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

John Turcich, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Shirlie Vaden, Glennie

Vicki Vannette, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Rekha Varghese, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Nathaniel Vincenty-Cole, Oscoda (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Hunter Vincenty-Cole, Oscoda (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Mason Vincenty-Cole, Oscoda (Foote, Cooke, Five Channels, & Loud)

Evelyn Visser, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Tony Visser, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Robert Visser, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Scott Visser, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Michael Vozel, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Caleb Walker, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Tom Wdowik, Owner, Sandcastle Beach Resort, AuSable Township

Kiernan Weeks

William Weibeler, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Jeff Weisenberger, Oscoda (Foote)

Whitney Whitburn, Iosco County (Five Channels, Loud, and Cooke)

Elton Whitford, Oscoda (Foote)

Colleen Wiegman, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

David Wiegman, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Kate Wiegman, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Craig Williams, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Zia Williams, Whittemore

Kayla Williamson, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

William Wilson, Oscoda

Tara Wilson-Anderson, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Shannon Wonnacott, Oscoda (Foote)

William Wood, Allegan (Calkins Bridge)

Vickey Woods, Oscoda (Foote)

Natalie Woods, Oscoda (Foote)

Anthony Wouters, Oscoda (Mio, Alcona, Loud, Five Channels, Cooke, & Foote)

Melissa Wyatt, Plainwell

David Yarbrough, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Pat Yarbrough, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Christine Yerkes, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Ken Yonker, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Christine Young, Owner, Perceptions Agency, Tawas City (Foote)

Joy Zdeblick, Allegan County (Calkins Bridge)

Carol Zigulich, Board Member, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Phillip Zigulich, Treasurer, Lake Allegan Association, Inc., Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Sharon Zigulich, Valley Township (Calkins Bridge)

Albert M. Zimmer, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Mike Zimmer, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)

Kathy Zimmer, Allegan Township (Calkins Bridge)